In most cases, no. Under Section 104(a)(2) of the Internal Revenue Code, money received on account of personal physical injuries or physical sickness is generally excluded from federal taxable income, whether paid by settlement or verdict. That usually covers medical expenses, pain and suffering, and lost wages tied to the injury. Punitive damages, interest, and some emotional distress payments not linked to a physical injury can be taxable.
Many people injured in car accidents, falls, and other incidents worry that a large share of their settlement will go to taxes. For typical physical injury claims, that fear is usually unfounded, but the details matter, especially when a case includes several types of damages.
What Is Usually Not Taxable
|
Type of Payment |
Usual Federal Tax Treatment |
|---|---|
|
Medical expenses from a physical injury |
Not taxable, unless you deducted them in an earlier year |
|
Pain and suffering from a physical injury |
Not taxable |
|
Lost wages tied to a physical injury |
Generally not taxable |
|
Emotional distress caused by a physical injury |
Generally not taxable |
|
Wrongful death compensatory damages |
Generally not taxable |
The key phrase is "on account of personal physical injuries or physical sickness." When the payment flows from a physical injury, most compensatory damages fall within the exclusion.
What Can Be Taxable
|
Type of Payment |
Why It May Be Taxed |
|---|---|
|
Punitive damages |
Punitive damages are generally taxable, even in a physical injury case |
|
Interest on a judgment or settlement |
Interest is generally taxable income |
|
Emotional distress without a physical injury |
Generally taxable, except amounts for related medical care |
|
Previously deducted medical expenses |
May be taxable to the extent you received a tax benefit earlier |
|
Property damage above your cost basis |
May be taxable in limited situations |
Employment claims, discrimination claims, defamation claims, and other cases without a physical injury follow different rules, and most of that money is usually taxable.
Why Settlement Wording Matters
The IRS often looks at the settlement agreement to understand what the payment was for. A clear allocation that ties the money to physical injuries supports the exclusion. Vague language or a large allocation to non-physical claims can raise questions. In cases involving both physical injury and other claims, such as an employment dispute with a physical assault, the allocation can make a real difference.
Structured Settlements
Some injured people receive their settlement as a series of payments over time instead of a single lump sum. For physical injury cases, payments from a properly arranged structured settlement are generally excluded from income in the same way a lump sum would be, including the growth built into the payments. A structure can provide steady income for long-term care needs, but it is usually difficult to change once it is set up, so it deserves careful thought before signing.
Do You Pay Taxes on the Attorney Fee Portion?
For a typical physical injury settlement that is excluded from income, the attorney fee portion is generally not a tax issue because the whole recovery is excluded. In taxable cases, such as some employment settlements, attorney fees can be treated in complicated ways. Our guide on how lawyers charge explains how contingency fees are calculated.
State Taxes and Government Benefits
Most states follow the federal treatment of physical injury settlements, but you should confirm your state's rules. Separately, a settlement can affect needs-based benefits such as Medicaid or Supplemental Security Income, even when it is not taxable. Special needs trusts and other planning tools may protect eligibility.
Practical Steps
-
Ask your attorney how the settlement agreement allocates the payment.
-
Keep a copy of the agreement and any closing statement.
-
Note whether any part of the payment is interest or punitive damages.
-
Talk to a tax professional before filing if your case involved non-physical claims.
-
Consider the effect on public benefits before accepting a lump sum.
If you are still deciding whether to settle, our state-by-state breakdown of car accident case values may help put an offer in context.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a car accident settlement taxable?
Usually not, when it compensates for physical injuries. Punitive damages and interest may be taxable.
Are punitive damages taxable?
Generally yes, even in a physical injury case.
Do I have to report a personal injury settlement on my taxes?
Excluded amounts generally are not reported as income, but taxable portions such as interest may be.
Is emotional distress compensation taxable?
It is generally not taxable when it flows from a physical injury, but often taxable when there is no physical injury.
Can a settlement affect my Medicaid or SSI?
Yes. Even nontaxable settlements can affect needs-based benefits without proper planning.
Find a Personal Injury Lawyer Near You
Best Local Law helps you compare personal injury attorneys by state and city and contact them directly to discuss your claim and settlement. Browse our personal injury lawyer directory.